Coral-mucus-associated Vibrio integrons in the Great Barrier Reef: genomic
hotspots for environmental adaptation
Aside
from the well-known symbiotic associations between corals and dinoflagellate
zooxanthellae (corals being largely dependent on zooxanthellae for certain
nutrients), the role of prokaryotes in the coral microbiodome has been the
target of recent study. The authors of this study (Boucher et al, 2011) focus on Vibrionaceae, a family of proteobacteria, which they
obtained from the mucus of the scleractinian coral Pocillopora damicornis from the Great Barrier Reef and
investigate their associations within the coral microbiodome.
Some
corals exhibit an apparent immunity to pathogens, although this is not the same
adaptive immunity observed in vertebrates, and the hypothesis aiming to explain
this immunity is known as the coral probiotic hypothesis. The authors make use
of the ideas behind this hypothesis to explore the relationship between Pocillopora
damicornis and its
associated Vibrios.
The
coral probiotic hypothesis suggests that the prokaryotic microbiome provides
pathogen resistance (notably to pathogens that may cause coral bleaching) to
the host coral and that this immunity insinuates a dynamic pattern of
antimicrobial production by non-pathogenic (commensal) bacteria, enabled by
horizontal gene transfer.
The
genetic element behind this immunity and its transfer (and also facilitating
antimicrobial resistance among pathogens), known as the integron, is a system
consisting of an integrase gene (intI) and an associated integration site (attI), where an integrase protein (IntI) catalyzes the insertion and removal of
gene cassettes. Gene cassettes typically consist of a single gene and
recombination site (attC)
and there may be up to 100 cassettes per integron array.
Integrons
are vital in the spread of both antimicrobials and antimicrobial resistance
among commensal bacteria and pathogenic bacteria. Their importance is evidenced
by a rise in proportion of Vibrio
16s rRNA genes sequenced by both commensal and pathogenic bacteria during coral
bleaching events.
The
authors cultivated coral mucus samples and amplified, cloned and sequenced the
genes present in the samples using PCR. They then acquired datasets from which
to draw comparisons via a variety of methods including screening the colonies
for IntI,
constructing fosmid libraries, sequencing Vibrio housekeeping genes, performing a
taxonomic assignment of Vibrio cultivars
by recA phylogeny and more as detailed in the article.
Their
main findings were that a diverse variety of Vibrio species were contained within the mucus
of P. damicornis and
that the mucus Vibrio-cassette
arrays were found to be highly dynamic (in that around 90% of their integron
associated gene cassettes were being actively shared, leaving around 10% at
most in common between cultivars). This meant that mucus Vibrio-cassette arrays could evolve more
rapidly in comparison to chromosomal genes, and the high mobility of genes
allows the integrons of mucus Vibrio to be viewed as strong evolutionary hotspots in genomes.
Comparisons to free living Vibrios
exemplified this observed high gene mobility. A direct link between the Vibrio cultivars, Vibrio coral pathogens and human pathogens was
demonstrated by the exchange of a subset of integron associated gene cassettes
(associated with antimicrobial resistance), exemplifying the extensive scale of
cassette sharing between microbial niches. This link may be useful in further
understanding how resistance antimicrobial and antibacterial drugs spreads in a
medical context.
The
diversity of cassette genes discovered in the coral mucus may show a
cooperative sharing of resources and a mutually beneficial association within
the coral microbiodome. This diversity and association allows quick adaptation
in response to threats from pathogens that may be viewed as immunity as
mentioned earlier. While beneficial to the coral microbiodome, this rapid
adaptation to threats does act as a selective pressure to pathogens,
facilitating an evolutionary arms race on both sides.
Boucher, Y. et
al., 2011. Coral-mucus-associated Vibrio integrons in the Great Barrier Reef: genomic hotspots for
environmental adaptation. ISME Journal (2011) 5, pp.962–972. Available at:
http://www.nature.com/ismej/journal/v5/n6/full/ismej2010193a.html
Hi Joseph,
ReplyDeleteGreat post! I find all this evolution talk very interesting although, as I've said in the blog previously, I can't help but question the evolutionary inferences made from the data. Is it really an example of evolution? Does having diverse gene cassettes make microbes better able to adapt? Well yes perhaps it does, but only if they contain genes that encode functions with fitness benefits. Okay, in this case they seem to have fitness benefits but was this directly tested as a hypothesis, or just inferred? Is it adaption or just environmental plasticty? And does this imply that microbes with small non-diverse, non-associated gene cassettes are poorly adapted and evolutionary cold-spots?